Renault Twingo ZE Ties With Smart Make It Better Than The ZOE

Not in the range – only 143 mi – but in expected battery pack lifespan.

As expected, the Renault Twingo ZE has finally arrived. It was just a matter of time to see it around, considering its close ties to the Smart Forfour: both share the same platform and are built at the Revoz plant in Novo Mesto, Slovenia. What most did not see coming was that these ties will make the Twingo ZE the best electric car Renault has ever offered. Unlike the ZOE, it has water-cooled batteries.

Gallery: 2020 Renault Twingo Z.E.

25 Photos

Although Nissan and Renault deny this has any impact on battery durability, the fact is that a water-cooling system protects EV packs in a much more efficient way. Check what Martin Graz, COO of Obrist Powertrain, told us when he was explaining the company’s vacuum fixation technology:

“We have both options, but, for the Mark II, we go with water cooling. It is under all conditions the better option, but with parallel hybrids, you need it. They face extremely high C rates under acceleration. 

When you have a vehicle with a 100 kW motor and a 100 kWh battery pack, there is a relatively low discharge demand rate: only 1 C. On the other hand, you have a 600 kg battery pack.

If you have an 85 kW motor and an 8.5 kWh battery pack, that is 10 C, which increases the cooling needs dramatically, but you have a small battery with low weight. Only the liquid cooling can deal with that in an adequate way.”

The Twingo ZE has a 22 kWh battery pack and a 60 kW motor. That would lead to a 2.7 C, but it has water-cooled cells anyway. The Renault ZOE can have a 52 kWh battery pack with a 100 kW motor. Has Renault considered 1.9 C acceptable for air cooling?

The company has been selling enough ZOEs not to worry about this. Anyway, we would have that in mind if we were about to buy an EV from the company. Tesla vehicles have water-cooled battery packs, and they have set the standard for the EV industry.